Recently a friend suggested that FT8 was probably making a dent in
activity on the RBN and taking away from CW in general. Out of
curiosity, I compared last week on the RBN (weekdays only, to avoid
contest activity) with the corresponding week in 2016, and was pleased
to see that the volume of RBN spots in 2017 was up about 8.4 percent
compared to the corresponding week in 2016.
Maybe growth would have been stronger if FT8 and WSPR had not been
introduced, but for a mature system near the bottom of the sunspot cycle
I think the continued upward trend is encouraging. The same week in 2016
was down 12.1 percent compared to 2015, which looks more like what I
would have expected this year.
I don't want to suggest that this is the last word. I did not take into consideration
the fact that the number of regularly-active RBN nodes increased year over
year during those two years.A much more accurate metric would to count the
number of unique CQs reported by the RBN; I didn't do that. Bottom line, though -
the RBN is pretty healthy.
Looking ahead to the big DX contest weekends, Felipe made a change in
the data flow at our server this week to sharply reduce the number of
operations that need to take place after spots are received from RBN
nodes and before each individual spot is sent out. We are hopeful this
will improve the server's reliability and handling of large volumes of
spots, as well as reducing the delay in their being posted on retail
servers around the world.
Feedback would be appreciated. ARRL CW Sweepstakes will probably be the
first major test.
Any plans to include FT8?
ReplyDeleteWould be helpful!
de WK2S
The problem is that there is no multi-band FT8 receiver/decoder analogous to the CW Skimmer/Skimmer Server family. On any given band, the FT8 op can see all the activity in the FT8 window.
DeleteHi Pete,
DeleteThis isn't completely true anymore.
Pavel has a dedicated WSPR application that will skimm all bands from the Red Pitaya and automatically report spots.
http://pavel-demin.github.io/red-pitaya-notes/sdr-transceiver-wspr/
73's 9V1RM
We're very impressed with Pavel's work. His 8-band receiver is now our standard for use of the Red Pitaya with the RBN.
DeleteFT8 poses a un ique set of challenges for the RBN. VE7CC tried picking up FT8 spots from PSK reporter, and found the volume overwhelming. We're experimenting with an approach that uses WSJT-X in conjunction with the Aggregator, to apply the same rules used for CW and RTTY spots on the RBN - that is, only CQ spots, and respotting stations on the same frequency only once every 10 minutes.
What we don't have is an 8-band receiver application, so I'm going to write to Pavel and see whether he can modify his 8-band WSPRnet receiver code to fit.
Pete
DeleteI had asked Pavel of this some months ago and had posed some questions and suggestions and have been following his forum here
https://github.com/pavel-demin/red-pitaya-notes/issues/689
I'm running Pavel's FT8 8 band skimmer now and have written some scripts to upload to PSKreporter, as well as share data via UDP on the LAN through the WSJT-X protocol with apps like GridTracker.
I've also got a telnet server running at k1ra.us.to 7373 that some of the local N. VA guys (K1HTV, K4SO, K7TRB) are using with RXClus and SpotCollector.
73
andyz - K1RA
Hi Andy - we're well aware of Pavel's great work. The author of the Aggregator is working with him on an interface between his FT8 receiver and the RBN, via UDP to the Agg. Meanwhile, a workaround involving WSJT-X and JT-Alert is running in Alpha test on a few sites - W3OA, WZ7I and KM3T. We are applying the same basic rule as VE3NEA did - re-spots only once every 10 minutes - to keep the number of spots usefully moderate. All this is experimental but we hope to go Beta soon and make things available to the wider community.
DeleteGreat Pete - look forward to seeing a self contained system that works directly with RBN, so I can dump the SDR/PC combo for the RP small form factor, standalone system. You can read more about what I've made available for the RP and various spotting services at the end of this discussion
Deletehttps://github.com/pavel-demin/red-pitaya-notes/issues/689
73
andyz - K1RA
Your site is very useful for me,Thanks for your sharing.
ReplyDeleteหนังสารคดี
Som you change your mind ?
ReplyDeleteRBN now is full of ft8 spamming reporter.. really no need for that.
Henry, I'm not quite sure what you're objecting to - we have only 3 RBN nodes currently testing spotting of FT8. and their volume so far is very small compared to the total flow on the RBN as a whole.
ReplyDeleteHi Pete, you'are right, but these 3 RBN spotting so much ! :)
DeleteYesterday evening on 17m 90% of spot was from WZ7I and KM3T on ft8... the same station around around and around again, with propagation wide open to NA (+20db), maybe one can disable ft8 spot when band is "so open" ?
Don't know, but it's quite frustrating when you'are searching cw station, for ft8 and other digital we have pskreporter and dx cluster also, fullfilled with ft8 spot.
Just my 2 cents..
Thank's for all anyway !
73's.